Yea it depends what your outlook is because these are 2 different pools. As an LP it is most advantageous to come in and come out of the pool when the ratio of 2 underlying tokens is relatively the same. In doing so you suffer 0 impermanent loss and gain all the fees from swaps that swung the price up and down but if you leave (withdraw) from the pool at the same ratio (eth/smol) as when you entered (made a deposit) you will end up w same ratio of smol + eth PLUS proportional swap fees. So you’ll come out with more Smols and more eth. The key point here is “same ratio of two underlying token” meaning magic/smol pool has a totally different dynamic. If you think price of smol and magic will increase in usd terms at relatively the same pace - this is the pool for you. If you believe smol + eth will increase/decrease in usd terms at relatively the same pace - this is the pool for you. NFA of course, hope this helps understand the difference between different LPs.